From discernment to deconstruction

In recent years, I have heard about Christians deconstructing their faith. Religious deconstruction was a new term for me. I never thought I would need to deconstruct my own faith because my faith in Christ is strong. But recently, I was thrown into an unexpected controversy at my church that has me taking apart what I believe.

Deconstruction is a personalized piecing apart of one’s belief system.  This may include political and religious views, gender roles, race and identity.

Rebekah Drumstra, 3  Stages of Deconstruction

Last year, the elders of my church (of which I am one) began discussing the fact that the denomination has become more liberal with respect to sexual orientation and gender identity. A couple of months ago, the pastor took the issue to the congregation and explained that if we don’t like what the PCUSA is doing, we can go through a process of discernment with the Presbytery and then vote as a congregation on whether to leave the denomination.

Then, the pastor went on a sabbatical for ten weeks and told us to spend the time reading and praying for discernment. When he comes back, the elders will have a special vote on whether to begin the process.

Based on everything I have heard, there are a lot more people in favor of leaving the denomination than staying. A few families have already left the church because they don’t want to be associated with a denomination that affirms LGBTQ and transgender people. People claim that they would welcome them to our church, but that they should be excluded from leadership and that they must be confronted with their sins.

I have been praying a lot and losing sleep struggling with this issue. I have been reexamining what I believe about scripture, what I believe about sexual orientation and gender identity, and what I believe my role is as a follower of Christ. It has been a spiritual struggle on steroids!

The truth is, I have been wrestling with the issues of sexual orientation and gender identity for years because I want to understand. I have gay and lesbian friends. My sister has a grandchild who is nonbinary. I already concluded that people don’t just choose to be different or nonnormative. I believe there are biological reasons for sexual and gender differences that have not yet been fully substantiated by science.

I’ve also had my doubts about the inerrancy of scripture. I have been taught the concept of solo scriptura – that all scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching and correcting. But there are parts of scripture that Christians do not follow today, like the Old Testament purity laws. When reading scripture, we take the culture into context. There are scriptures that I don’t take literally. I question the accuracy of the translations of ancient texts. Scholars made decisions about what to include in the Bible. I do believe God inspired the authors, but the authors and translators were not infallible.

All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the servant of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work.

2 Timothy 3:16-17

The gospels, the words of Jesus, are the most useful for teaching and rebuking me for my own sins. Jesus told us the most important commandment: love God with everything you’ve got and love your neighbor as yourself. He did not focus his ministry on sins of the flesh but on sins of the heart. He saved his harshest criticisms for the religious leaders.

The criticism that strikes me as being very relevant to modern-day hypocrites is this one:

But woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you shut the kingdom of heaven in people’s faces. For you neither enter yourselves nor allow those who would enter to go in.

Matthew 23:13

The big thing that I can not overlook in my discernment process is that the same people who do not want to be associated with a denomination that affirms LGBTQIA+ believers are willing to align themselves with someone who is truly wicked. They choose to support him. His many sins include adultery, sexual abuse of women, bullying and verbally abusive language, profound dishonesty, racism, hatred, malice, the desire for vengeance and retribution, corruption. and greed.

For ten years, I have struggled with being a minority in my church because I refuse to align myself with a man who is the antithesis of Christ. I stayed in the Presbyterian church because my pastors focused on the word of God. But the hypocrisy of the people is finally pushing me out the door. I will be visiting other churches while our pastor is away.

Finally, what is my role as a follower of Christ? It’s loving my neighbor as I love myself, which means loving them unconditionally. It’s doing my best to make sure that no one misses out on the grace of God. It’s leaving judgment to God. It is not shutting the door to the kingdom of God in people’s faces.

Me and Bobby Beddia

As I anticipated my birthday this year, the math nerd in me realized that my age will be the same as my birth year (’63) – a once in a lifetime phenomenon. I wondered if there is a name for this birthday. I found out that there is a name for it. It was coined almost 20 years ago.

From a November 2007 article in The New Yorker:

“Named after New York City firefighter Bobby Beddia, it is a fun coincidence that only occurs during even-numbered years.
The concept was born when Beddia discussed the milestone with visitor and mathematician Rhonda Roland Shearer at his fire station in 2006. Tragically, he passed away in the line of duty later that day. Afterward, mathematician Barry Cipra coined the term “Beddian Birthday” in his honor.”

I had many minutes of fun thinking about what I prefer to call doubling birthdays. I’ve thought about when each of my seven siblings had or will have their Beddian birthday. For example, my youngest sister, Annie, will be 70 in 2040. (That’s easy math. 70 × 2 = 40). She’s seven years younger; double the difference in our ages is 14 years from now.

I thought about how some people will have to be really old, not just kind of old like me, to celebrate their Beddian birthday. A person born in the year 2000 will have to live to be 100!

Then I read that the aforementioned mathematician, Barry Cipra, came up with what he called the Beddia Theorem. He determined that at any given time, you can calculate the number of ages that are pre- or post-Beddian. Cipra said that the ages will fall into two separate time spans, except for years ending in ’98, ’99, or ’00.

  • In odd-numbered years: There are exactly 50 pre-Beddian ages.
  • In even-numbered years: There are exactly 49 pre-Beddian ages.

I spent a few minutes confused, then several minutes more figuring out the time spans to prove his theorem. I got it wrong the first time. (I initially started with 1927 and ended with 2026.)

1926-1963 Post-Beddian; 38 ages
1964-2000 Pre-Beddian; 37 ages
2001-2013 Post-Beddian; 13 ages
2014-2025 Pre-Beddian; 12 ages

It works. This year, there are 49 ages of people who have not yet celebrated a Beddian birthday. 37+12=49

Cathy’s theorem says that in even-numbered years, there will be two years of birth, 50 years apart, celebrating Beddian birthdays. This year, that’s 1963 and 2013. A child born in 2013 will turn 13 in 2026.

I plan to celebrate my childish enthusiasm for this silly milestone with two scoops of ice-cream!

🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨

Forever Friends

What’s a chapter of your life you’d title “The Hard Years” — and what got you through it?

I call my teenage years “The Hard Years” of my life. My parents divorced when I was twelve, leaving Mom with seven kids ranging from sixteen down to three. She had another child when I was thirteen. Mom had custody of us, and, unfortunately, she made some selfish and short-sighted decisions.

I was blessed with one older brother and sister, three younger sisters, and two younger brothers. I have to admit that I didn’t think of the youngest as blessings at the time.

My siblings, especially those closest to me in age, went through the tough things with me. (My older sister Cindy is two years older, and my sister Amy is a year younger than me.)

My sister Cindy was like a second mom to all of us, making sure we all got ready in time for school.

We moved the summer after my sophomore year and started going to a new school. Amy was with me. Midway through my junior year, Mom moved us to another town. Again, my sister Amy was with me, hating the new school as much as I did.

Hard things are so much easier when someone goes through them with you.

Turn your mind to good things

What’s the best way to deal with negative thoughts?

It’s easy to focus too much on negative things. But we choose what we think about. We have some control over our thoughts.

One way to deal with negative thoughts is to direct your mind to positive things. Think about what is right, what is admirable – anything that is praiseworthy.

Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable—if anything is excellent or praiseworthy—think about such things.

Philippians 4:8

Having said that, there is a reason we have negative thoughts, and we shouldn’t suppress or ignore those reasons. If you’re feeling negatively about your life, it’s a sign that something needs to change. If you’re thinking negatively about yourself, you need to work on your self-esteem.

Preparing to tell my story

I have been staying after church for a group study on “everyday evangelism,” which made me think about my faith story. I’ve shared some of what follows before on my blog but have never spoken about it publicly.

Salvation

Dad always took us kids to church. Mom stayed home. She grew up going to church like he did, so I didn’t understand why she didn’t come with us.

When I was about nine years old, my Sunday school teacher led me to faith in Jesus. I don’t recall the Bible story. I don’t recall the words of her invitation. I don’t remember the words of my response. But for years, I could remember the feeling of joy.

In retrospect, I can see that God’s timing was perfect. The hardest years of my life were ahead of me, but I had a faithful friend with me. My faith gave me hope.

But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect…

1 Peter 3:15

I started reading the Bible every day. In sixth grade, I went to AWANA Bible studies. I was active in Youth for Christ until we moved after my sophomore year.

Meanwhile, my home life was tumultuous. My parents argued and even separated a couple of times. I thought they were arguing about the lack of money because there were too many mouths to feed.

Mom and Dad divorced when I was twelve. Mom got custody of the seven of us. Dad moved to another city and remarried within a year or so.

We kids continued to go to church on our own.

The year after the divorce, Mom had another baby. We questioned her about the father. He was someone we knew; my older sister and I babysat his children a few times. Mom managed to keep their relationship a secret.

I was afraid people would find out that our mother had a child outside of marriage and that they would judge us. So when asked about my family – even years later – I pretended that my dad was the father of all of us.

After the divorce, Mom was free to do whatever she wanted. She had a few more sexual relationships, but they were no longer a secret. In pursuing those relationships, she made decisions that were not in our best interests.

Mom told us that Dad had a vasectomy after their fourth child, but that it obviously didn’t work since they had three more kids. I learned the truth as an adult. Mom told my younger sister, child number five, that her father was a coworker who had raped her. She also told the next two kids who their real fathers were.

Knowing what happened to my mom when she was a young mother, I could better understand the choices she made. I can imagine why she wasn’t comfortable in church. I know she felt some shame, or she wouldn’t have lied and kept so many secrets.

The Other Prodigal Daughter

Mom was clearly not a good example for us kids to follow. All three of my younger sisters got pregnant in high school.

I was determined to go to college and make a better life for myself, so I didn’t take any chances. But in a way, I followed in my mother’s footsteps. When I moved away to college, I stopped going to church. I gave into temptations.

I met my husband at my first job after college. He was not a believer. His family did not go to church. I knew that the Bible says not to be unequally yoked, but I told myself it was okay. He is a good man.

The Prodigal Daughter Returns

In the years that I didn’t go to church, I missed it. I knew I should start going again. But it took something shocking to get me back.

We lived in a suburb of Denver. On April 20, 1999, two high school students murdered a teacher and several students at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado. I was devastated. I couldn’t imagine what would make kids do something so evil.

I needed to be with other people of faith. I went to the church that I often drove by,  Hope United Methodist. It was comforting to be with people who shared my faith in God.

My faith story is a long one. It has its ups and downs. It shows that when you belong to Jesus, he will never let you go.

My sheep listen to my voice; I know them, and they follow me. I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; no one will snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father’s hand.

John 10:27-29

God loves me just as I am – flawed, selfish, struggling to be good. No matter how messed up I am, He sees a person worthy of mercy and forgiveness.

I have hope because God is good all the time. I have hope because He is in control. He is faithful; he has been with me through all the storms of my life. He will not let me go.